Lee’s Hawaiian Islander in Lyndhurst has been a Northern New Jersey institution since 1972 — and despite recurring rumors of its sale or closure, it’s still going strong. While it’s here, go.
You don’t go for the food — though the Chinese-Polynesian menu is solid, with entrees from $12 to $32.50. You don’t go for the service, which can be kind, chaotic, occasionally gruff — and somehow part of the charm. You’re not there to review the mixology, but Lee’s Mai Tais and Pina Coladas pack a punch.
You don’t go because you miss Maui — you go because you miss Mrs. Helen Roper (IYKYK).
This is not a place that tries to impress you. It’s vintage tiki, a little worn around the edges — but that’s the point. And lately, it’s even looking better: the waterfall wall is flowing again, and the space feels cleaner than it has in years.
For a Good Time, Call Lee’s
You go for the flaming volcano Pu Pu Platter ($29.50 for two) and over-the-top tropical drinks served in novelty mugs (around $11.50). You stay for the gloriously judgment-free karaoke.
There’s the moment when the drinks kick in, and the room comes alive – when a group of bank tellers belts out “War (What Is It Good For),” when strangers sing along, when a server grabs the mic. It always feels a little on the verge of becoming unhinged, but somehow never does.
Some places are all about the food. Others, like the Soup Nazi or the late, great Shopsin’s, you go for the experience. Lee’s is ours — warts and all. Don’t change a thing. Go there to celebrate a birthday, a last day at a job, a first date with someone you hope has a sense of humor, or just to break up a dull week with something fun and memorable. And if you can, score a table on the balcony level so you can watch it all from above.
How to “Do” Lee’s
- Lee’s Hawaiian Islander is open Tuesday–Sunday, noon–9:30 p.m.
- Karaoke runs Friday and Saturday, 8–10:30 p.m., with a $20 food-and-drink minimum per person (no bar seating). Reservations are a must on weekends — call ahead; there’s no real online system.
- 21+ only.
- Parking is limited (small rear lot + street), so honestly — a trip to Lee’s might be Uber-worthy.
Lee’s Hawaiian Islander
Asian Hawaiian…