There is a pie shop in Knoxville, Tennessee, where the recipes on the menu trace back not to a culinary school or a test kitchen, but to two grandmothers who knew exactly what a great pie should taste like. This shop carries that legacy into every crust and every filling, offering a lineup that feels personal rather than mass-produced.
The shop sits in the Bearden neighborhood and has built a loyal following among locals and out-of-towners alike. Whether someone is picking up a full 9-inch pie for a family gathering or grabbing a 4-inch mini for a solo treat, this place has a way of making pie feel like a proper occasion worth planning around.
The Signature Pie That Put This Shop on the Map
Ask almost anyone who has visited Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Knoxville what to order, and the I-40 pie comes up almost immediately. Named after the major interstate that cuts through Tennessee, this pie has become the shop’s most talked-about offering.
The I-40 combines pecan, chocolate chips, and coconut in a filling that leans rich and satisfying without being overly heavy. It reads like a dessert bar reimagined as a pie, and that combination has earned it a devoted fan base…