LAKELAND, Fla. – Polk County Sheriff’s Office homicide detectives have made a swift series of arrests in the double murder that rocked the Secret Cove neighborhood of Lakeland on Monday, May 12, 2025. Six individuals are now in custody, facing a range of charges in connection with the deaths of 19-year-old Davin Boutwell and 38-year-old Nathaniel Jones, Jr.
According to PCSO, four of the arrested individuals are charged with two counts of felony murder, while the remaining two face various charges related to the case.
The suspects have been identified as:
- Alexander Zarion Colon-Martinez, 17, Lakeland: Charged with 1st Degree Murder (2 counts), Attempted Armed Robbery, and Tampering with Evidence.
- David Yule, Jr., 15, Lakeland: Charged with 1st Degree Murder (2 counts), Attempted Armed Robbery, Conspiracy to Commit Armed Robbery, Possession of a Firearm by a Juvenile, and Violation of Probation.
- Anthony Scott Roush, 18, Lakeland: Charged with 1st Degree Murder (2 counts), Attempted Armed Robbery, Conspiracy to Commit Armed Robbery, Contributing to Delinquency of a Juvenile (2 counts), and Violation of Probation.
- Kristian Xavier Guzman, 23, Lakeland: Charged with 1st Degree Murder (2 counts), Attempted Armed Robbery, Conspiracy to Commit Armed Robbery, Negligent Child Abuse (2 counts), Contributing to Delinquency of a Juvenile (2 counts), and Violation of Probation.
- Jessica M. Chambers, 19, Lakeland: Charged with Accessory After the Fact to a Capitol Felony, Conspiracy to Commit Armed Robbery, False Information to Law Enforcement in a Felony Investigation, and Contributing to Delinquency of a Juvenile (4 counts).
- Isabella Brooke Farley, 21, Lakeland: Charged with Accessory After the Fact to a Capitol Felony, Conspiracy to Commit Armed Robbery, Negligent Child Abuse (2 counts), False Information to Law Enforcement in a Felony Investigation, and Contributing to Delinquency of a Juvenile (2 counts).
The investigation revealed that the tragic events unfolded around 1:26 PM on Monday when Davin Boutwell arrived in the Secret Cove neighborhood to conduct a drug transaction. Colon-Martinez met Boutwell at his white Mercedes near the intersection of Ned Engle Boulevard and Pirates Way, while Yule and Roush stood nearby. Guzman allegedly remained in the getaway vehicle, a silver Nissan Altima…