If you have ever promised yourself you would save room for dessert, Stauffer’s Cafe & Pie Shoppe makes that promise easy to keep. This Lincoln favorite serves homey plates and an irresistible pie list that locals whisper about like a delicious secret. Pull up a chair, breathe in the cinnamon and butter, and let the glass pie case work its magic. You will leave planning your next slice before the first bite is gone.
The Signature Banana Cream Pie
Banana cream pie at Stauffer’s is comfort in a cold slice. The crust flakes with a gentle crackle, then gives way to silky custard that tastes like childhood birthdays and Sunday suppers. Fresh banana coins tuck into the filling, and a swoop of whipped cream crowns each forkful.
You notice the balance first: not too sweet, mellow vanilla, lingering creaminess. The chill of the pie plays against warm coffee from the bottomless pot. Order early, because regulars know this one goes fast.
Ask for an extra napkin and a corner seat near the window. Watch people smile when their plates arrive. You will probably do the same, then plan your next visit before your plate is clean.
Classic Chicken Fried Steak Plate
Golden, peppery breading shields tender beef that cuts with a butter knife. The gravy arrives in generous rivers, speckled with black pepper and memories of family tables. Mashed potatoes sit beside it like clouds, ready to catch every savory drip…