Sharing is caring!
In a city that knows its comfort food, Casetta Kitchen and Counter has become the lunch spot friends whisper about and coworkers guard like a secret. Tucked on West Washington Avenue, this stylish counter turns out sandwiches that make people cross town—and rearrange meetings—to get a bite. With house-baked breads, sharp flavors, and a menu that changes just enough to keep you curious, it’s easy to see why lines form before noon.
If you think you know the best sandwich in Madison, Casetta is ready to challenge your rankings.
Why Madisonites Cross Town for Casetta
Casetta Kitchen and Counter isn’t just convenient—it’s destination-worthy. Locals rave about the balance of textures: crisp greens, tangy peppers, and bread that’s fresh enough to perfume the room. The long counter hums at lunch, a sign that regulars know to arrive early during the tight 10:30 AM–2:30 PM window…