Planning a truly unforgettable romantic dinner can feel overwhelming, especially when Valentine’s Day rolls around, and every restaurant claims to be the perfect spot for couples. From candlelit tables to indulgent tasting menus, the idea of the “most romantic restaurant” is often subjective. That’s why lists backed by real diners tend to carry extra weight. When thousands of experienced food lovers agree on what sets the mood best, it’s worth paying attention, particularly for couples searching for a romantic restaurant that feels genuinely special.
According to Yelp Elites, who are known for their high standards and detailed reviews, one restaurant stands above the rest. Their ranking of the Top 100 romantic restaurants in the U.S. pulls from years of ratings and reviews, with strict criteria around quality, consistency and atmosphere. Taking the number one spot is a destination that has become synonymous with luxury dining, exceptional service and unforgettable date nights.
Why This Restaurant Earned the Top Spot
Cafe Monarch in Scottsdale, Ariz., claimed the title of America’s most romantic restaurant thanks to its refined ambiance and meticulously curated dining experience. Located in the heart of Old Town Scottsdale, this upscale restaurant is best known for its elegant four-course, prix-fixe menus and its focus on seasonal, premium ingredients. From the moment guests arrive, everything feels intentional, from the softly lit dining spaces to the attentive tableside service.
Yelp reviewers frequently highlight the atmosphere as a major draw, with fireplace-adjacent seating, lush outdoor courtyards and private dining rooms that feel intimate without being stuffy. One diner wrote that the experience was superior in every respect, praising the ambiance, food, wine list, and service in equal measure. That balance is exactly what couples look for when planning a romantic dinner, especially for milestone celebrations or Valentine’s Day.
What Couples Can Expect From the Experience
The four-course menu evolves with the seasons, offering carefully paired options such as hamachi and tuna, pork belly, scallops, short rib and premium steaks or seafood for the final course. Prices vary depending on selections, ranging from around $145 to well over $200…