A Miami landowner and Crown Castle could have incurred roughly $460,000 to $1 million in combined legal fees, by Wireless Estimator’s estimate, in a dispute that produced a $40,001 jury verdict. The fight over fiber optic cables buried beneath and beyond a utility easement on property next to a Miami tower site has gone through a federal jury trial, two landowner appeals to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, and a certified question to the Florida Supreme Court. The cables remain in place, as far as the court record shows.
The landowner, RJ’s International Trading LLC, won at trial. But its effort to make Crown Castle pay its lawyers suffered what is likely a decisive setback on October 29, when the Florida Supreme Court ruled that a prevailing-party attorney’s fee clause in the easement does not run with the land.
Writing for the court, Justice Jamie R. Grosshans said a prevailing-party fee provision “comes into play only after the dispute has been finally resolved on the merits and serves solely to allocate litigation costs between the parties. It is wholly unconnected to the use, enjoyment, or occupation of the property itself or any interest therein.” Four justices joined her opinion, and Justices Barrios and Tanenbaum concurred only in the result, making the outcome unanimous. The Florida Land Title Association and homebuilders Lennar Homes and U.S. Home Corp. weighed in as friends of the court. With $5,606.20 in prejudgment interest, RJ’s judgment totals $45,607.20.
Six years of litigation over buried fiber…