A Wisconsin Deputy Held an I-39 Driver 17 Seconds Past the Citations for a Drug Dog, Then a Federal Judge Denied Him Qualified Immunity

A federal judge in Milwaukee ruled on Oct. 29 that a Marquette County, Wisconsin, deputy unlawfully extended a traffic stop on Interstate 39 by 17 seconds so a drug dog could finish its work, and that the deputy cannot claim qualified immunity in the driver’s lawsuit.

U.S. District Judge J.P. Stadtmueller of the Eastern District of Wisconsin granted the driver partial summary judgment on liability in Burnside v. Marquette County, No. 2:25-cv-00195, which names Deputy Brendan Cutrell. The order leaves one question for trial: how much Cutrell owes in damages.

The stop, by the clock

The stop dates to December 2023. Cutrell pulled the driver over on I-39 and wrote citations for speeding and window tint. The timestamps in the order show the dog beginning its inspection of the car at 10:57:16 p.m., while Cutrell was still talking with the occupants. He finished delivering and explaining the citations at 10:57:24 p.m. The dog alerted at 10:57:41 p.m., and Cutrell kept the occupants there until it did…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS