Sharing is caring!
Wisconsin winters were made for pasties. Nothing warms the hands, the belly, and the soul like a golden, flaky pasty fresh from the oven. These hearty pockets of meat, potatoes, and vegetables aren’t just food—they’re history, comfort, and pure Midwestern pride rolled into one. Each shop has its own twist: some stick to classic fillings, while others sneak in cheese, mushrooms, or secret family spices. But the result is always the same: a crispy crust that holds tender, flavorful filling, begging to be eaten with a steaming cup of coffee.
Get ready to explore six of the best pastie havens in Wisconsin, where every bite tells a story and every shop invites you to savor the cold.
Reynold’s Pasty Shop – Milwaukee
Reynold’s Pasty Shop, nestled in Milwaukee since 1956, exudes authenticity with pasties crafted fresh daily. Imagine biting into a flaky crust, revealing a hot, savory filling, just as the winter wind howls outside…