Minnesota’s west metro has plenty of chain slices, but ElMar’s New York Pizza is the spot where homesick New Yorkers and curious Minnesotans suddenly find themselves arguing over which slice to order next. 🍕
From the foldable pies and garlicky red sauce to the bagel pop-up that draws early-morning lines, this locally owned shop has quietly become a destination for anyone chasing that classic corner-by-the-slice feeling—without leaving Plymouth. 😋
How ElMar’s New York Pizza won Plymouth’s hearts
Locals first came for the promise of true New York–style pizza in a suburban strip mall, then kept coming back because the pies actually delivered—crisp yet chewy crust, balanced sauce, and toppings that feel straight out of a borough slice joint.
Regulars rave that the slices hit “all the points of the New York slice,” from the light char to the way the tip folds just right for that iconic one-handed bite. 🍕🗽…