There is a small bakery in Bethany, Oklahoma, where cheesecake is taken very seriously, and the people who visit once tend to plan their return before they even finish their first slice. The menu reads like a dessert lover’s wishlist, with flavors ranging from classic strawberry to peach cobbler-topped creations that somehow make perfect sense.
The owner greets every customer like a familiar face, and the passion behind each recipe is obvious from the very first bite. This is the kind of place that gets mentioned in food guides, earns five-star reviews from people who drove 30 minutes just to get there, and quietly becomes a personal tradition for everyone who discovers it.
Where You Can Find This Cheesecake Haven
The address is 3934 N College Ave, Bethany, OK 73008, and that stretch of road in the Oklahoma City metro area is exactly where you will find Not Cho Cheesecake doing its thing, Tuesday through Saturday, without much fanfare but with a whole lot of flavor.
Bethany is a quiet city just west of Oklahoma City, and this bakery fits right into its neighborly, no-fuss character. The shop does not try to be flashy from the outside, and that understated quality makes the experience feel a little like discovering a well-kept secret…