Pennsylvanians know a good gyro when they taste one. These Greek-inspired sandwiches combine seasoned meat, fresh veggies, and tangy tzatziki sauce wrapped in warm pita bread. From Pittsburgh to Philadelphia, the Keystone State has some seriously amazing spots where locals line up for their gyro fix. Here are seven places that Pennsylvanians swear serve the best gyros in the state.
Mike & Tony’s Gyros — Pittsburgh
Don’t let the modest storefront fool you—this Pittsburgh gem hides culinary magic inside. The moment you walk in, the aroma of perfectly seasoned lamb and beef cooking on the vertical spit tells you you’re in for something special.
Locals rave about the balance here: tender meat with just the right crispy edges, fresh pita that’s never soggy, and tzatziki with enough garlic to notice but not enough to overwhelm. The portions satisfy without being excessive.
What sets Mike & Tony’s apart isn’t fancy decor or trendy additions—it’s the consistency of a neighborhood spot that’s mastered their craft. Even on busy days, the line moves quickly and the quality never wavers.
New York Lunch (East Avenue) — Erie
Tucked away in Erie, New York Lunch has become something of a local legend. Regulars swear by their gyro’s distinctive taste—a secret that keeps bringing people back for decades…