PENNSYLVANIA — New court filings reveal major developments in the viral Pittsburgh dog-kicking case that captured widespread attention earlier this year. Two women accused of attacking a small dog in a residential neighborhood now have reduced charges, and a critical hearing has been postponed until 2026.
Felony Charges Reduced for Both Suspects
Officials identified the women in the footage as Lagashia Shante Williams, 46, and her daughter Graciela Amar, 18. Prosecutors confirm their original felony charges—which included animal cruelty, brandishing an imitation firearm, and filing a false police report—have been downgraded to misdemeanors. Court filings state both women pleaded not guilty and were released on bail pending further court action.
Key Judicial Diversion Hearing Pushed to 2026
A judicial diversion hearing, which could allow the women to avoid a traditional conviction if granted, was originally scheduled for November 21, 2025. The hearing is now rescheduled for January 16, 2026, delaying the case for more than a year. The change has sparked renewed concern from community members who feel the system is moving too slowly for a case that stirred such intense public reaction.
Dog Suffered Serious Injuries but Is Improving
The dog involved, a small white dog named Gigi, suffered significant injuries including liver damage and leg trauma. Veterinarians say she continues to improve with ongoing treatment. A fundraiser created for her medical care has already raised more than $20,000, reflecting strong public support and outrage over the incident.
Public Reaction Remains Strong
Across social media, many users described the reduced charges as “disappointing,” with some calling for tougher animal cruelty laws. Advocates point to this case as an example of the legal challenges in pursuing felony-level convictions in animal abuse incidents, even when video evidence sparks national attention.
The case will move forward in early 2026 as the court reviews whether judicial diversion is appropriate. If granted, the women may be able to avoid a standard conviction depending on compliance with court requirements. Until then, residents and animal advocates continue to demand accountability as Gigi recovers…