At a Glance: Best Pizza Near Hutchinson Island
- Closest to the beach: Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza and Nonna’s, both on S Ocean Dr
- Best thin and crispy crust: Ian & Kye’s Pizza
- Most authentic Italian: Gigi’s Italian Restaurant and Due Fratelli’s Pizzeria
- Best NY-style slice: Big Apple Pizza & Pasta
- Wood-fired option: Original Santos Wood Fired Pizza Restaurant
Pizza on Hutchinson Island and the Surrounding Jensen Beach Area
Finding great pizza near Hutchinson Island means knowing which spots locals actually return to week after week. The barrier island sits within Martin County, and the surrounding Jensen Beach and Port St. Lucie communities give visitors and residents a surprisingly deep bench of independently owned pizzerias to choose from. Whether you want a slice steps from the Atlantic or a full Italian dinner inland, the options below cover every style and budget.
Beachside Pizza: Walking Distance from the Water
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza
Brock’s Surfside Grill & Pizza has been feeding beach crowds at 10545 S Ocean Dr in Jensen Beach since 1996, making it one of the most established pizza joints on South Hutchinson Island. The ocean-blue and yellow corner spot is a reliable stop for thin-crust pies, garlic knots, subs, and cold drinks at the bar. Lunch runs 11 AM to 3 PM and dinner from 3 to 9 PM, with happy hour from 3 to 6 PM daily.
The pizza here is consistently praised for its thin, crispy crust, and the beachside vibe keeps people coming back even after a long day on the sand. The outdoor bar area is newer and popular with regulars who like to linger. Staff are consistently described as attentive and quick to make things right when an order goes sideways.
📍 10545 S Ocean Dr, Jensen Beach, FL 34957…