When summer rolls around in New York, locals flock to their favorite seafood shacks for fresh catches and seaside vibes. From Brooklyn’s bustling waterfront to Montauk’s laid-back shores, these beloved establishments serve up everything from buttery lobster rolls to crispy fried clams. Whether you’re a New Yorker or just visiting, these eight seafood spots offer authentic flavors that keep customers coming back year after year.
1. Red Hook Lobster Pound – Brooklyn, NY
Tucked away in Brooklyn’s historic Red Hook neighborhood, this maritime gem started as a simple seafood market before evolving into a full-fledged eatery. The Maine-style lobster rolls, served on toasted split-top buns with just enough mayo and butter, have developed a cult following among city dwellers.
Wooden picnic tables and nautical decor create a casual atmosphere that feels miles away from the urban hustle. What makes this spot special isn’t just the seafood – it’s the owners’ commitment to sustainability and direct relationships with Maine lobstermen.
2. Brooklyn Crab – Brooklyn, NY
Perched on a three-story structure with panoramic views of New York Harbor, Brooklyn Crab offers more than just seafood – it delivers an experience. The Maryland-style blue crabs, doused in Old Bay seasoning and served with wooden mallets, transform dinner into a delightfully messy adventure.
Kids and adults alike enjoy the ground-floor mini-golf course and cornhole games while waiting for their orders. The rooftop deck becomes magical at sunset, when the Statue of Liberty silhouette appears against the orange sky, making even longtime New Yorkers fall in love with their city all over again.
3. Randazzo’s Clam Bar – Brooklyn, NY
Since 1963, this Sheepshead Bay institution has been serving what locals swear is the best marinara sauce in the five boroughs. The famous “sauce” isn’t actually marinara at all but a fiery, rich tomato concoction that elevates their fried calamari to legendary status…