Mud-covered tires, a broken yard lamp and a rent notice now sit at the center of a murder trial in Monroe County, according to WHAM.
Prosecutors say Jamie Busch strangled her sister, Penny Busch, after Penny tried to evict her from a Honeoye Falls home. They allege Jamie dumped the body in the Genesee River and tossed three cellphones in a dumpster. Deputies found Penny’s Jeep parked oddly behind the house during a welfare check in October 2024…