You showed up for a rum runner, but the plates steal the spotlight before the garnish even hits the glass. Florida’s tiki scene is serving craveable coastal flavors that make you forget the drink menu exists. From beach shacks to legendary supper club stages, these spots prove tiki food can be fresh, inventive, and wildly satisfying. Bring an appetite and a sense of adventure, because your next favorite bite is waiting by the water.
Sandbar Seafood + Spirits – Anna Maria, Florida
Sea breezes drift across Sandbar Seafood + Spirits, carrying that briny promise only a true Gulffront spot can deliver. You come for umbrella drinks, but the menu takes over fast with crispy grouper sandwiches, citrusy ceviche, and stone crab when in season. The hushpuppies are lightly sweet and dangerously shareable.
Order the blackened fish tacos, stacked with slaw and a punchy key lime crema. If you want comfort, the shrimp and grits bring smoky heat over velvety corn. Portions are generous, but you will still pick at the last fries.
Sunsets paint the deck in tangerine light, and suddenly dessert feels mandatory. Try the key lime pie, tart and cool, and toast the tide.
Caddy’s Treasure Island – Treasure Island, Florida
At Caddy’s Treasure Island, toes hit the sand before you even crack a menu. You think drinks first, then a server drops coconut shrimp crisped perfectly and you pivot. The mahi tacos burst with fresh pico and lime, a simple combo that lands every time…