A recent story out of California was kind of shocking to me. As I was scrolling the latest automotive news, I saw an article about how California DMV has been auctioning off cars that have been towed without informing the owners. Typically, in the state I live in (North Carolina), the DMV or whoever towed your car has to make reasonable attempts to contact you before they just auction off your car. However, the Golden State doesn’t have to abide by that rule. Some really expensive cars have hit the auction block as a result and all the money gets banked by the DMV. So, how is this legal? Here’s what you need to know about how California auctions off towed cars, plus what you can do if this happens to you.
The Surprising Reality of Towed Car Auctions
In California, towed cars can be sold at auction without the owner’s knowledge. If a car sits unclaimed for long enough, towing companies can legally sell it to cover their costs. Shockingly, any surplus from the sale goes to the California DMV, not the owner. For instance, a Lamborghini Murciélago Roadster sold at auction left nearly $100,000 in surplus funds with the DMV. Owners have up to three years to claim the money, but most aren’t even aware they’re entitled to it. This process raises questions about transparency and fairness.
Legal Loopholes That Enable This Practice
State laws permit towing companies to initiate lien sales if owners don’t pay their debts. These laws don’t require the DMV to notify owners about surplus funds from the sales. As a result, many owners never realize they could reclaim money left over after their vehicles are sold. From 2016 to 2024, the DMV collected over $8 million from such sales. The lack of mandatory notification creates a loophole that disproportionately affects unsuspecting owners.
The DMV keeps unclaimed surplus funds permanently if not collected within three years. This policy has turned into a significant revenue stream, with collections increasing annually. In 2023 alone, the DMV received over $1.3 million from auction surpluses. Luxury cars aren’t the only source; even average vehicles often generate surplus funds. Owners’ lack of awareness means the DMV keeps a substantial amount of unclaimed money.
How This Practice Impacts Low-Income Californians
Towing fees can quickly become unaffordable for low-income individuals, trapping them in a financial bind. Many rely on their cars not just for transportation but also as a place to sleep. Losing a vehicle can disrupt employment and worsen financial instability. The lack of notification about surplus funds further disadvantages those who can least afford it. Legal aid organizations argue that the current system unfairly targets vulnerable communities.
The DMV’s Defense and Public Backlash
The DMV defends the practice, citing compliance with state laws. However, critics argue that legal compliance doesn’t equate to ethical practice. The lack of transparency has sparked outrage among car owners and consumer advocates alike. Public perception is increasingly negative as more people learn about the practice. Some are calling for legislative changes to require the DMV to notify owners about unclaimed funds.
Mandatory notification to owners about surplus funds is a proposed reform. Advocates suggest that the DMV should be required to inform owners directly, not just through public databases. Extending the claim period beyond three years could also help. Some propose creating an independent body to manage surplus funds and ensure fair practices. Transparency and accountability are key demands from reform advocates. Without changes, the DMV’s practice of keeping unclaimed funds is likely to face increasing scrutiny.
A Legal Practice That Feels Unjust
While this is technically legal, California DMV’s practices are undoubtedly questionable from an ethical standpoint. Should they just be allowed to auction off people’s cars without informing them? The owner should at least have a chance at purchasing the car back or paying the fines owed to recoup their vehicle. Mandatory notification and extended claim periods could potentially make the system more equitable. That said, if you are a California resident whose car was auctioned off, there is still hope. You can request a refund or contact the DMV Lien Sale Unit at (916) 657-7617. Just remember, you only have three years post-sale to request a refund…