I’ve eaten a lot of pie in Florida, but nothing prepared me for the tart, creamy perfection that landed on my table at Yoder’s Restaurant in Sarasota.
This unassuming diner tucked into the Pinecraft neighborhood serves up a Key Lime pie that has locals plotting their lunch schedules around it. The slice arrives with a golden graham-cracker crust and a filling so bright you can practically taste the sunshine.
After one bite, I understood why people drive across the county just to snag a whole one to go.
Where You’re Headed (And When It’s Open)
Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village sits at 3434 Bahia Vista Street in Sarasota, right in the heart of Pinecraft. You’ll find it open Monday through Saturday for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, but Sundays are reserved for rest…