Yoder’s Fresh Market is a beloved Amish‑style grocery and deli in Sarasota, Florida, offering fresh produce, baked goods, jarred specialties, and a taste of Pinecraft’s unique Amish community in one tidy, well‑stocked shop. Located alongside the larger Yoder’s Amish Village complex, it has become a regular stop for locals and visitors who want farm‑market quality with small‑town hospitality.yelp+3
Name, Address, And Setting
Yoder’s Fresh Market is part of Yoder’s Amish Village, 3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL 34239, in the heart of the Pinecraft neighborhood, the winter home of many Amish and Mennonite visitors. The market sits just steps from the famous Yoder’s Restaurant and next to the bakery and gift shop, turning this stretch of Bahia Vista into a compact food destination.amishamerica+4
Travelers describe Yoder’s Fresh Market as an “Amish grocery store” and “local store with good baked goods,” noting that it feels more like a country market than a standard supermarket. Outside, benches and a full‑size mock‑up of a horse and buggy, along with a mural on the side of the building, give visitors an instant sense of Pinecraft’s Amish flavor before they even step inside.tripadvisor+2
What You’ll Find Inside
The market focuses on fresh produce, Amish pantry items, and baked goods, much of it sourced from Amish or Mennonite suppliers or made in‑house. Shelves are described as “spotless” and “full of fresh produce, baked goods, jams, juices, and unique items not commonly found in regular grocery stores.”wanderlog+2…