If you love comfort food that tastes like it came straight from Grandma’s kitchen, Der Dutchman in Sarasota is your next must-stop. The Amish buffet and bakery lure you in with fried chicken, fresh pies, and warm hospitality that keeps plates and smiles full. With a glowing 4.6-star reputation and a gift shop upstairs, people plan entire days here without regret.
Come hungry, pace yourself, and prepare for seconds, then dessert.
1. All-You-Can-Eat Homestyle Buffet
Der Dutchman’s buffet is the reason people plan their whole day around this spot. You will find golden fried chicken, carved turkey, mashed potatoes, creamed corn, and a salad bar stacked with fresh toppings. It feels like Sunday dinner any day of the week, with friendly servers keeping drinks filled.
Go slow, sample broadly, and save room for dessert. The hot food stays hot and the cold stays cold, even when the dining room is buzzing. Free soft serve with the buffet is a cheerful touch, especially after a plate of savory comfort…