PHOENIX (AZFamily) – Naughty or nice… why not both?. When Grace Bradley (Judy Greer) is tasked with putting on her church’s annual Christmas pageant, it draws sneers and jeers from some of the more conceited congregants. Her job is made even more difficult when the Herdmans, a clan of juvenile delinquent siblings, interject themselves into the pageant and basically take it over. Can Grace and the Herdmans win the public’s affection by performing The Best Christmas Pageant Ever?