It’s often said that appearances can be deceiving, and this rings true for restaurants as well. The outside of a place or its location doesn’t always reflect the quality of the food inside. Throughout the Sunshine State, you’ll find locals eager to share their favorite hidden gems, whether it’s that charming “greasy spoon” or a cozy “hole in the wall” known for incredible cuisine. Previously, we explored the top unassuming eateries in Florida, but we realized there were simply too many to include in just one article. So, we’ve expanded our list to introduce you to some exciting new dining destinations, focusing on the best under-the-radar restaurants in Florida. Take a look!
1. Red Wing Restaurant, Groveland
You’ll be tempted to sample each dish from breakfast through dinner (if you’re up for it) at this upscale eatery that exudes a cozy, rustic charm in Central Florida. The Red Wing Restaurant offers an experience that goes beyond a simple, unassuming steakhouse.
2. Pudgees’ Eatery & Market, Floral City
If you’re craving a true Chicago-style hot dog or a burger that’s simply irresistible, Pudgees’ is the place to be (and don’t forget to grab some hand-cut fries on the side). This charming little spot exemplifies the beauty of simplicity. Once a modest, unassuming eatery named Pudgees’ Hot Dog Stand, it has since transformed into a vibrant new establishment called Pudgee’s Eatery and Market. Fresh appearance—same amazing flavors!
3. Star Fish Company Market & Restaurant, Cortez
It’s only natural that a genuine fishing village in Florida would serve as the ideal spot for fresh, local seafood. The meals are straightforward, and the atmosphere is laid-back, but you’ll savor every mouthful at the Starfish Company Market.
4. Florida Cracker Kitchen, Brooksville
The Florida Cracker Kitchen is here to celebrate Florida’s cowboy culture and Southern heritage. With a menu that features delectable dishes like shrimp and grits and homemade corned beef hash, your taste buds are in for a treat!
5. Sandwich Inn, Gainesville
Sandwich Inn takes pride in being the oldest locally-owned eatery in Gainesville, satisfying the appetites of locals since 1963. Stop by in person or take advantage of our drive-thru for delicious burgers, refreshing shakes, and breakfast sandwiches available all day long.
6. 12A Buoy, Fort Pierce
Don’t be fooled by appearances; a restaurant’s charm isn’t always found in its outside look. Step inside 12A Buoy, and you’ll be delighted by the exquisite seafood and mouthwatering side dishes it has to offer.
7. Peebles Bar-B-Q, Auburndale
For those in search of exceptional barbecue, Peebles is a must-visit. This charming eatery has been a family-owned staple since 1947. Peebles offers all your beloved classics, along with BBQ-stuffed potatoes and refreshing salads, each crafted to perfection.
8. Balkan Cafe, Jacksonville
If you enjoy the tastes of the Mediterranean, you’re likely to savor Balkan cuisine as well. Should you find yourself unsure about what to choose, the welcoming team at this tucked-away treasure will gladly assist you in discovering a delightful dish.
9. DJ’s Clam Shack, Key West
DJ’s Clam Shack was established by two guys from the Northeast who settled in the Keys, merging the finest aspects of Northern and Southern seafood into a singularly amazing dining experience. Be sure to swing by for their delicious conch fritters and mouth-watering lobster rolls when you’re in Key West.
Have you visited any of these charming, off-the-beaten-path eateries in Florida? We’d love to hear about your favorites in the comments! And if your top pick isn’t included here, tell us about the best hidden gems in your area so we can check them out for future recommendations.
There are many more concealed culinary treasures in Florida waiting to be discovered. If you’re in the mood for fantastic food, don’t miss out on these options. Miami’s Little Havana is a vibrant culinary hotspot, and if you’re in the area, consider joining an exciting foodie tour through Little Havana!