Taste the Renowned Key Lime Pie at Florida’s Beloved Blue Heaven Cafe

Florida is renowned for its delicious key lime pie, but not every café or bakery will deliver the best experience. To truly savor this iconic dessert, you need insider knowledge of the top spots. One place that stands out in Key West is Blue Heaven, where they serve a key lime pie that is truly exceptional. Prepare yourself for a treat; Blue Heaven offers a version of this classic dessert that you simply have to try!

Blue Heaven in Key West, Florida is one of the coolest, most well-known breakfast spots in the area.

A colorful, weathered wooden house surrounded by lush greenery and a blue picket fence, with a sign reading "Ice Heaven."
TripAdvisor docneneng

Visitors will flock from near and far to savor the Lobster Benedict, indulge in our generously filled omelettes, or enjoy the delectable pancakes drizzled with rich maple syrup.

A plate of eggs Benedict topped with crab meat, served with a side of fruit and drinks in a lively restaurant setting.
TripAdvisor sivya L.

Visitors also gather to enjoy the stunning tropical climate while savoring a delightful brunch on the outdoor patio, nestled beneath the lush greenery.

A bustling outdoor restaurant with colorful umbrellas, filled with diners enjoying meals under large trees.
TripAdvisor Brad F.

If you want to truly experience the charm of this cozy little café, be sure to indulge in a slice of their famous key lime pie.

A slice of pie with a golden meringue topping, creamy filling, and a crumbly crust on a white plate.
TripAdvisor Susan M.

When you think of a classic key lime pie, you might envision a thin, smooth slice resting in a distinct crust, perhaps adorned with a hint of whipped cream on top. However, that’s not what you’ll encounter in this version.

A slice of pie with a fluffy meringue topping on a plate, accompanied by two forks.
TripAdvisor akustoff

The key lime pie at Blue Heaven is a breathtaking portion, topped with a delightful toasted meringue that adds a delightful twist to the classic recipe.

A person holding a large, fluffy, orange dessert on a pie crust, surrounded by lush green plants.
Facebook Blue Heaven

This delightful key lime pie has garnered a reputation nationwide, likely due to its towering peaks of baked meringue. Moreover, stumbling upon an authentic key lime pie in Key West feels akin to discovering a treasure trove.

Slices of meringue pie on white plates, arranged on a kitchen counter.
Facebook Blue Heaven

Blue Heaven is a charming destination that draws visitors in with its quirky decor, the friendly cats wandering the property, and its delightfully fluffy pancakes. Whether you’re captivated by the unique ambiance, the playful feline companions, or the mouth-watering food, there’s something special waiting for everyone at this enchanting spot.

A plate with two golden-brown pancakes, a small metal syrup pitcher, and butter packets on the side.
TripAdvisor markus273

…we suggest you stay for one of the most delightful key lime pie experiences you can find.

A colorful sign reading "Blue Heaven" surrounded by lush greenery and tropical plants.
TripAdvisor knightime05

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS