Just for fun, we decided to ask some folks from Illinois who they think are the most crushable celebrities, and the results were pretty surprising. I’m a gal who has had her fair share of hard-core celebrity crushes. My celebrity love story began with Jonathan Knight of New Kids on the Block and then ventured to Jonathan Brandis, (from the movie Ladybugs), Tom Cruise, Brad Pitt, Leonardo DiCaprio, and for almost two decades my celebrity-loving heart has belonged to Keith Urban.