Man Files New Tort Claim Against Henry County Sheriff’s Office

HENRY COUNTY, Ind. — A Henry County man has filed a formal Notice of Tort Claim against outgoing Sheriff John Sproles and several county leaders, claiming the sheriff’s department unlawfully withheld public records that would show how many times deputies and jail staff searched his personal information in a police database—after an earlier records request revealed his name had been run more than 60 times in a single year.

The three-page notice, filed on Oct. 26, 2026, under the Indiana Tort Claims Act by Spiceland resident Elvante Riddick, is the latest in at least a dozen tort claims and federal civil rights lawsuits lodged against the Henry County Sheriff’s Office during Sproles’s tenure.

In an exclusive interview, Riddick described a three-year conflict with the department that he says escalated from a 2023 traffic stop into a disputed police impersonation charge, an arrest on a nonexistent warrant, and repeated background checks by officers he had no contact with.

“It became like a game of chess,” Riddick said. “I would do something, and then Sproles would counterattack.”

The April Records Denial and Spoliation Demand

According to the tort claim, Riddick submitted a written request under the Indiana Access to Public Records Act (APRA) on April 28, 2026, seeking audit and query logs from the department’s Spillman and Mobile Data Terminal (MDT) systems showing how frequently his name or personal identifying information had been accessed…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS