Tashiena Combs walked out of prison a free woman on Tuesday, more than 25 years after an Oakland County jury convicted her of first-degree murder in a 1999 shooting. Oakland County Circuit Judge Nanci Grant vacated the conviction and ordered Combs’s immediate release, finding that she had received ineffective assistance of counsel at trial and suffered actual prejudice as a result. Combs is now 50 years old.
The case, reported by The Oakland Press, centers on a previously undisclosed conflict involving Combs’s own defense attorney. Per a news release cited by the outlet, the attorney concealed that he was also representing Combs’s sister in a case stemming from the same fatal shooting, and that he had an undisclosed sexual relationship with the sister at the time of trial. That conflict, according to the release, shaped how he presented Combs’s defense to the jury.
Oakland County’s Conviction Integrity Unit investigates claims that a conviction’s integrity has been undermined and can recommend a remedy to the prosecutor. It cannot overturn a conviction itself: only a court can vacate a conviction. The unit’s published eligibility rules focus on claims of actual innocence supported by new, credible evidence, but also allow it to investigate other claims in the interest of justice—an avenue relevant to Combs’s challenge to the fairness of her trial.
Witnesses Silenced, Then a Midtrial Reversal
The news release detailed specific ways the alleged conflict damaged Combs’s case. The attorney kept two key witnesses from testifying even though their accounts reportedly supported Combs’s claim of self-defense and disputed the prosecution’s theory of premeditation, according to the release relayed by The Oakland Press. He also failed to prepare Combs to testify, then abruptly told her midway through the roughly one-week trial in January 2000 that she would have to take the stand anyway…