Just as the saying goes, “don’t judge a book by its cover,” the same holds true for dining experiences. Throughout Ohio, you’ll discover numerous unassuming “hole in the wall” restaurants that serve up mouthwatering dishes, defying their modest appearances. If you enjoy uncovering these culinary treasures, you should definitely check out these eateries (ranked randomly), which we believe represent 11 of the finest hidden gems in Ohio.
1. The Maid-Rite Sandwich Shoppe (Greenville)
Known for its renowned Maid-Rite, Cheese-Rite, and Big Jim sandwiches, this charming sandwich shop boasts an intriguing custom. Patrons hang their chewed gum on the “Wall of Gum” before stepping inside to savor what many consider Ohio’s finest loose meat sandwich. (Featured: Big Jim.) This unique establishment can be found at 125 N Broadway St., Greenville, OH 45331.
2. Remo’s Hot Dogs (Gallipolis)
For only $4.25, you can enjoy a tasty footlong hot dog, paired with chips and a refreshing drink. This fantastic hot dog spot is an ideal pit stop during your road trip. Visit Remo’s Hot Dogs at 241 2nd Ave., Gallipolis, OH 45631, and indulge in a meal featuring their unique secret family sauce.
3. Uptown Grill (Athens)
This walk-up window has become a popular spot for Ohio University students looking for a bite to eat late at night. Whether you’re in the mood for lunch, dinner, or a delicious chicken and waffle sandwich after hours, this is the place to be. You’ll find it conveniently located at 11 W Union St., Athens, OH 45701.
4. Sand Bar (Huron)
Tucked away in Huron, OH, at 54 McKinley St., the Sand Bar offers more than just its well-known pizza, burgers, and perch. This charming bar and American restaurant boasts a diverse menu filled with exceptional, homemade specials that are definitely worth trying. Don’t miss out on the tasty dishes that make the Sand Bar a standout destination for diners.
5. Funday’s: The Root Beer Stand (New Philadelphia)
Tucked away in plain sight, this charming drive-in diner is a hidden treasure. Two standout items on the menu are the Cheeseburger topped with Grilled Onions and the Creamed Chicken sandwich, both of which are favorites among diners. You can find Funday’s at 1345 4th St. NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663.
6. Oler’s Bar & Grill (Findlay)
Nestled in a cozy corner, this charming “hole in the wall” Mexican eatery is a hidden gem run by a dedicated family. The Tex-Mex dishes served here are truly exceptional, complemented by their delightful margaritas. Oler’s Bar & Grill can be found at 708 Lima Ave., Findlay, OH 45840.
7. Tilton Hilton (Lakeview)
If you’re looking for a unique dining experience after a day enjoying Indian Lake, look no further than Tilton Hilton. Famous for its oversized burgers that are sure to impress, this charming spot is not only fun but also offers a whimsical atmosphere with its tilted floors. Plus, if you’re out on the water, you can conveniently dock your boat right next to the restaurant. Tilton Hilton is situated at 10861 Country Rd 293, Lakeview, OH 43331, making it a perfect stop for locals and visitors alike.
8. Bagel Street Deli (Athens)
Once you try a bagel from this one-of-a-kind deli in Athens, your perception of bagels will be forever changed. At Bagel Street Deli, situated at 27 S Court St., Athens, OH 45701, you can delve into an array of signature bagel sandwiches that offer a delightful twist on this classic treat.
9. Leaning Tower of Pizza (Mansfield)
For delicious pizza and subs that will have you returning for seconds, check out the Leaning Tower of Pizza located at 180 Lexington Ave., Mansfield, OH 44907.
10. Windward Passage Restaurant (Upper Arlington)
In the dimly lit dining room, the ambiance transports you into an underwater world as you savor the finest shrimp cocktail and seafood meal you’ve ever tasted. (Featured: Surf n’ Turf.) Windward Passage Restaurant can be found at 4739 Reed Rd., Columbus, OH 43220.
11. Crabill’s Hamburger Shop (Urbana)
Now in its third generation under local ownership, this quaint burger spot, featuring only eight seats at the counter, specializes in miniature burgers. Once you’ve experienced their offerings, you’ll find that White Castle’s sliders seem almost amusingly small in comparison. Crabill’s Hamburger Shop can be found at 727 Miami St., Urbana, OH 43078.
Have you dined at any of these hidden gem eateries? Do you think they deserve the title of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Ohio? We’d love to hear your thoughts! Are there any other cozy, lesser-known spots in Ohio that you would suggest? Share your experiences and recommendations with us!