There’s nothing quite like stumbling upon a hidden gem of a restaurant that delivers an incredible dining experience, surprising your palate with each bite. In Ohio, you’ll find a multitude of unassuming eateries that delight with their mouthwatering dishes, proving that great food often comes in modest packages. By embracing the idea of not judging a restaurant by its exterior, you can uncover some extraordinary culinary treasures. Below, we’ve highlighted seven of the most unexpectedly delightful dining spots across the Buckeye State that are sure to impress.
1. Windward Passage Restaurant (Upper Arlington)
The dimly lit dining room creates an ambiance reminiscent of being deep underwater as you savor what might be the most exquisite shrimp cocktail and seafood meal you’ve ever tasted. For more details on the latest menu offerings, be sure to visit the Windward Passage Restaurant’s website.
Featured: Surf n’ Turf. It’s every bit as delicious as it appears in this image, served at one of Ohio’s most unpretentious dining spots.
2. Mac’s Pizza Pub (Cincinnati)
Alongside their delectable pizzas, Mac’s offers a variety of mouthwatering options, including burgers, wings, and a host of other tasty dishes. Be sure to check out one of the many Mac’s Pizza Pub locations near you!
3. Star of India (Athens)
Nestled close to the Ohio University campus, there exists a treasure trove of genuine Indian flavors that will satisfy your culinary cravings. This restaurant stands out as one of Ohio’s best-kept secrets, offering a cozy and unassuming atmosphere that belies its exceptional offerings. The good news is that you can now enjoy their delectable dishes from the comfort of your home by ordering online!
4. Jerusalem Pizza and Grill (Columbus)
If you’re in central Ohio and craving delicious Mediterranean food, particularly gyros, you won’t want to miss the options available along Cleveland Avenue. Surprisingly, pizza pairs wonderfully with Mediterranean flavors, making this a must-visit culinary destination. Be sure to add Jerusalem Pizza & Grill to your dining list and explore their tempting menu filled with delectable dishes.
5. Crabill’s Hamburger Shoppe (Urbana)
Currently owned by its third generation of locals, this charming little burger spot boasts only eight counter seats and is known for its delightful mini burgers. After tasting their offerings, even White Castle’s sliders might seem amusingly oversized! This gem is widely regarded as one of Ohio’s top dining destinations, having earned a beloved place in the community. Be sure to follow them on Facebook to keep track of their hours and special promotions!
6. The Root Beer Stand (Sharonville)
Located just outside Cincinnati, this charming spot offers a delightful selection of family-crafted root beer alongside classic American dishes, including coney dogs and crispy french fries. With delicious foot-long cheese coneys and their signature homemade root beer, it’s hard to resist! The menu features an array of options that go beyond the basics, making it one of the top mom-and-pop eateries in Ohio.
7. Hamburger Wagon (Miamisburg)
For almost a century, a beloved rolling cart has been a staple in Miamisburg, serving up a straightforward yet delicious burger. The twist? This unique spot skips the cheese, ketchup, and mustard. Instead, it relies solely on onions and pickles, allowing patrons to savor the rich flavor of the burger itself without distractions. The Hamburger Wagon has become a must-visit destination in downtown Miamisburg. Don’t forget to visit the Hamburger Wagon’s website to discover interesting tidbits about its long history and explore the various menu options available!
What do you think? Do you think this is a comprehensive list of good and unassuming restaurants in Ohio? What other unexpectedly delicious eateries in Ohio should be added to the list? Let us know in the comments below!