A New Amish Restaurant & Market Brings Heartwarming Flavor to New Jersey
There’s a buzz in the Garden State food scene—a vibrant new Amish market and restaurant have opened their doors, bringing authentic Pennsylvania Dutch flavors, farm-fresh ingredients, and neighborly hospitality to lucky locals and hungry travelers. Located in Mullica Hill, this market isn’t just a place to shop—it’s a destination to explore, eat, and experience the best of Amish tradition right in New Jersey!
Mullica Hill Amish Market & Restaurant
Address: 108 Swedesboro Rd, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062
Website: amishmarketmullicahill.com
Nestled near antique shops and rolling farmland, Mullica Hill Amish Market is a lively hub where more than a dozen Pennsylvania Dutch vendors gather each week. From early morning Thursday through Saturday, visitors find bustling food counters, butchers, bakeries, and a full-service country restaurant, along with fresh produce and hand-crafted goods. The market’s standout feature: everything is fresh, homemade, and bursting with the flavor the Amish are known for.
Favorite Food Items & Market Must-Trys
- Beilers Donuts: Famous for fluffy, oversized donuts in classic and creative flavors—crispy outside, pillowy inside, and glazed with the perfect sweetness.yelp
- Pulled Pork & Mac & Cheese: Comfort food with a smoky twist; fans rave about the tender meat and rich, cheesy pasta—so good people return two days in a row to order the same meal.yelp
- Soft Pretzels: Warm, buttery twists made all day, including unforgettable pretzel sandwiches, loaded with meats, cheese, and local veggies.yelp
- Fresh Meats: The butcher counter is legendary for top-quality steaks, ribs, and chicken specialties, including BBQ beef rib platters and mouthwatering kielbasa—customers say the meat is “simply the best!”.yelp
- Pickle Bar: A cornucopia of fresh, crunchy pickles in bold brine flavors for snacking or sandwiches, plus a massive deli for cold cuts and sides.yelp
- Breakfast Specialties: From pancakes and omelets to breakfast sandwiches and homemade jams, breakfast here is a highlight for both regulars and visitors.tripadvisor+1
- Produce & Pantry: Fresh fruits, root veggies, homemade jams, preserves, and exceptional breads beckon from wooden bins and shelves—most sourced directly from Lancaster County Amish farms.amishmarketmullicahill
- BBQ Chicken & Wings: Rotisserie and fried specialties keep lines moving, especially for market-goers looking to fuel up on the go.
Rave Reviews & Community Buzz
The Mullica Hill Amish Market has quickly won over foodies with its blend of nostalgia, quality, and value. Just check out what delighted visitors have to say:
- “Wow! What an awesome market this is. I could spend lots of time and $$ here. They have every counter and treat you could ask for. This is the best amish farmers market I’ve gone to without having to go to PA.”
- —Aaron C., Yelp.yelp
- “We came to visit Philadelphia and randomly found this Amish Market on Yelp and we had to check it out! Each business had tons of amazing foods! Our favorites were the pretzels and the pickle bar! So delicious – like a huge deli, but on steroids!”
- —Krista R., Yelp.yelp
- “The pulled pork and Mac and cheese are so good we came back the next day to order the same.”
- —Review, Mullica Hill Amish Market.yelp
- “The beef rib, tender, beefy, and soooo good. Well worth the price! The lima beans had these chunks of pork in them too and it just elevated them to the next level. The kielbasa had a great snap and smoke flavor.”
- —Review, Mullica Hill Amish Market.yelp
- “Always a great meal…The meat is the BEST!!”
- — Tripadvisor.tripadvisor
This Amish market is praised for variety, quality, and customer-oriented service, and offers a comforting, nostalgic feeling described as “the most beautiful food you’ve ever seen” and “takes you back to the Fifties”. The market is also wheelchair accessible, has ample parking, and serves both takeout and sit-down meals.tripadvisor
Atmosphere & Hours
- Open: Thursday-Friday 8am to 6pm, Saturday 8am to 4pm.
- Warm, bustling, and welcoming—shoppers are greeted by friendly Amish staff who manage food stations, answer questions, and share stories from Lancaster County and beyond.
- Each vendor is independent—shoppers pay at each counter, which adds an authentic market feel.
Insider Tip
Visit early for the bakery and donut counter (they sell out fast!), and plan your trip around breakfast or lunch for the full food experience. If you’re exploring on a weekend, allow extra time for browsing jams, crafts, meats, and more!…