Amid the buzz of college life and Main Street traffic, a new kind of comfort has arrived in Newark, Delaware: Meadow Brook Amish Kitchen, tucked just off the main corridor at 214 Farm Lane, Newark, DE 19711. This cozy Amish-style restaurant trades fast food and game-day grills for slow-simmered soups, fried chicken, and pies that taste like they came straight from a farmhouse kitchen. For travelers used to grabbing a quick bite between brewery stops, university tours, and tax-free shopping, Meadow Brook offers a completely different pace—and it’s already becoming the place locals tell their out-of-town friends not to miss.
A Farmhouse Retreat On The Edge Of Campus
Set a few minutes from the busiest stretch of downtown, Meadow Brook Amish Kitchen feels like a country detour cleverly tucked into Newark’s everyday rhythm. Inside, the space leans simple and warm: wood tables, ladder-back chairs, enamelware on shelves, and black-and-white photos of fields and barns that could easily be from nearby Pennsylvania Dutch country. The sign at 214 Farm Lane might be modest, but the glow from the windows and the steady stream of cars in the gravel lot say plenty.
From the moment baskets of warm rolls and crocks of apple butter land on the table, phones tend to stay face-down. One University of Delaware staff member described it this way: “I walk in with my brain still spinning from campus meetings, and by the time the chicken and noodles arrive, I’ve shifted into a different world entirely.”
What’s On The Menu: Comfort First
The menu at Meadow Brook leans into Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch traditions with just enough flexibility to suit college-town tastes. Expect:
- Buttermilk Fried Chicken with mashed potatoes, gravy, and buttered corn
- Chicken & Homemade Noodles, served in a rich broth or ladled over mashed potatoes
- Slow-Roasted Pot Roast with carrots, onions, and a deep, beefy gravy
- Ham Steak With Pineapple Glaze, paired with scalloped potatoes and coleslaw
- Farmer’s Vegetable Plates with baked corn, stewed tomatoes, green beans with ham, and buttered carrots
Breakfast and weekend brunch turn into an event of their own—scrapple, home fries, biscuits with sausage gravy, baked oatmeal, and thick-cut bacon that has become a minor obsession in local foodie circles. A Newark regular joked, “If I schedule brunch at Meadow Brook, I don’t bother pretending I’ll eat light. That’s not the point.”
Desserts Worth Planning Around
Dessert is not an afterthought here; it’s part of the destination. A glass-front case near the host stand at Meadow Brook shows off a rotating lineup of pies and sweets:
- Shoofly pie with a sticky molasses base and crumb topping
- Dutch apple pie with a shattering top crust
- Peanut butter cream pie in towering slices
- Seasonal fruit pies—peach, cherry, blueberry—as produce allows
- Whoopie pies and sticky buns for those who “don’t want a whole slice” (they usually end up getting both)
One visiting parent summed it up: “We came for dinner during move-in weekend and ended up coming back just for pie before we drove home. My daughter now refers to it as ‘finals week fuel’—apparently a slice of peanut butter pie can fix anything.”
What Diners Are Saying
For a relatively new spot, Meadow Brook Amish Kitchen has already inspired the kind of word-of-mouth money can’t buy. Newark residents who used to trek to New Castle or up into Pennsylvania for Amish-style meals now talk about having “their own Amish place” at 214 Farm Lane. “It saves us a drive and scratches the same itch,” explains one local. “You get that same feeling of being looked after—like someone’s aunt is in the kitchen making sure you didn’t leave hungry.”
Students and younger diners have embraced it as a change of pace from pizza and burgers. One senior said, “I bring friends here when they visit from out of state. Meadow Brook is my ‘this is Delaware you didn’t expect’ move.” Another frequent guest noted, “Portions are huge, prices are fair, and the leftovers are legendary. One pot roast dinner fed me for two more lunches.”…