Memphis Judge Suppresses Teen’s Statement in ‘Watermelon Man’ Killing Over Intellectual Limitations



A judge has verbally agreed to suppress a statement made by a teenager charged in the 2023 killing of beloved Memphis fruit vendor John Materna, known throughout the community as “Watermelon Man.” The ruling follows defense arguments about the teenager’s reported intellectual limitations and the circumstances surrounding his questioning, leaving Materna’s family devastated and raising important questions about how juveniles are interrogated in serious criminal investigations.

The Big Picture:

  • The victim: John Materna, 76, was a longtime Memphis fruit vendor affectionately known as “Red the Watermelon Man.” On May 15, 2023, he was shot during an alleged robbery while selling watermelons near the intersection of Homer Street and Wayne Avenue. He died from his injuries approximately two weeks later. Materna had reportedly spent decades selling fruit throughout the Memphis area and had become a familiar presence in his community.
  • The Defendant: Demarion Tackett was 15 when investigators connected him to the case. He was subsequently charged with murder and robbery-related offenses, and his case was transferred from juvenile court to adult criminal court. Earlier courtroom reporting indicated that Tackett told investigators he was driving the vehicle involved in the attempted robbery but was not the person who shot Materna. That distinction is important as the case proceeds.
  • The suppressed statement: In a statement provided to FOX13, Materna’s family said the Shelby County District Attorney’s Office informed them that Judge Jennifer Fitzgerald had verbally granted the defense motion to suppress Tackett’s May 26, 2023, confession. The family described the development as devastating and expressed outrage over the decision. The available reporting describes a verbal ruling; the complete written order and its legal reasoning have not been established in the reporting reviewed.
  • The defense’s argument: FOX13 reviewed a motion filed by Tackett’s defense attorney earlier this year. The filing references an evaluation by a doctor who reportedly found that Tackett demonstrated intellectual limitations. On a test evaluating sentence comprehension, the doctor documented an ability equivalent to a 2.3 grade level. The defense also questioned the circumstances of the interrogation, noting that Tackett’s mother had reportedly been invited by investigators to leave the room before questioning about the shooting began.


Between the Lines:

  • Understanding the reliability of confessions: A confession or incriminating statement can become an important piece of evidence in a criminal prosecution. However, a person’s age, intellectual abilities, understanding of their rights, and the circumstances surrounding questioning can become significant legal considerations. The reported assessment does not, by itself, establish a mental illness or determine whether a statement was voluntary.
  • A family still seeking answers: For Materna’s loved ones, the latest ruling represents another difficult development in a case that has stretched across several years. Their reaction highlights the emotional consequences families experience when significant evidence becomes the subject of courtroom disputes. At the same time, the court must evaluate whether evidence meets the legal standards required for use in a criminal trial.


What’s Next:

Tackett is expected back in court in January 2027. The prosecution will continue addressing the case following the judge’s decision on the disputed statement. The suppression of one piece of evidence does not dismiss the murder charges or establish the defendant’s innocence. The remaining evidence and subsequent court proceedings will determine how the prosecution moves forward.


15 Minutes of Murder Producer’s Quote:…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS