Five years after his son was gunned down in a mass shooting on May 30, 2021, Clayton Dillard II returned to the northwest Miami-Dade shopping plaza where it all happened. He lit candles, taped posters to the storefront and turned the sidewalk into a makeshift memorial. Standing outside the supermarket that now sits where the El Mula Banquet Hall once operated, Dillard called for the toughest punishment the law allows for the men accused in the ambush. For families and neighbors, the vigil was a blunt reminder that their grief is still raw and that key legal questions from that night are still hanging in the air.
What happened at El Mula
Just after midnight on May 30, 2021, a group of masked gunmen opened fire on a crowd gathered outside the El Mula Banquet Hall. Three people were killed and about 20 others were injured in a barrage that investigators later labeled one of the deadliest mass shootings in Miami-Dade County history. Those findings, along with coverage of the continuing prosecution of suspects, were reported by the Miami Herald.
Surveillance video and the scene
Security footage from the plaza shows a white Nissan Pathfinder rolling in before three masked attackers jump out and unleash gunfire. Police later said they collected roughly 100 shell casings from the parking lot. The banquet hall is gone, replaced by a supermarket, a visible sign that the block has moved on in appearance even as the community still lives with what happened there. Those scene details were documented by CBS News Miami.
Prosecutions and timeline
One defendant, Davonte Barnes, went to trial in 2023. Jurors convicted him on multiple counts for his role as a lookout, and he was sentenced to life in prison, according to coverage by Local 10 and court records, which also show he has filed an appeal.
Four other men accused of being inside the Pathfinder remain behind bars and are expected to face trial in 2027. Prosecutors have moved to waive the death penalty for two of those defendants, as reported by the Miami Herald. Key arrests in the case were announced at a June 13, 2024, press conference, according to a media advisory from the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office.
Father’s vigil and demand for justice
At the anniversary memorial, Dillard described his grief as a daily fight and said he wants “the harshest possible punishment” for the men charged in connection with his son’s death. “No mercy!” he told reporters, adding that he sometimes “self-medicates” by speaking to his son. CBS News Miami captured him lighting candles and placing posters in front of the supermarket that now stands where the banquet hall once hosted parties.
Legal outlook…