Napa’s long-quiet Franklin Station post office is one step closer to trading mail for minibars. On Tuesday, city planning commissioners signed off on a revised plan to turn the shuttered downtown landmark into an upscale, five-story hotel, paired with a second five-story building that would add for-sale units and ground-floor retail. The vote pushes the drawn-out redevelopment toward a City Council showdown while keeping the building’s Art Deco façade as the visual star of the project.
According to City of Napa documents, the Franklin Station II plan features two new five-story structures: a hotel with up to 120 rooms and a mixed-use building with ground-floor parking and retail. That second building would include 37 new for-sale hotel units, while three existing condominium units on the site would be converted into additional for-sale units. In all, roughly 121,480 square feet of new construction would rise around the historic structure, with about 4,650 square feet of the existing post office retained and restored under the city’s historic-preservation rules.
Preservation, Price Tag and Pushback
Franklin Station’s historic bones are not going anywhere without a fight. Local preservationists previously secured a conservation easement and related covenant for the 1933 building, overseen by Napa County Landmarks, which has highlighted the post office’s Art Deco flourishes and its 1985 listing on the National Register of Historic Places. Saving it will not be cheap: project representative Jeff Dodd told The Press Democrat the plan needs roughly $10 million to $13 million up front just to make the old structure seismically safe and usable again.
Neighbors and Commissioners Weigh In
At the planning commission meeting, many neighbors cheered the idea of breathing new life into the vacant landmark, but enthusiasm cooled when the conversation turned to parking. Some downtown businesses warned that losing nearby street parking would sting. Billco’s owner, Jeri McCulloch, objected to giving up the parking lot her customers rely on, and several speakers raised questions about impact fees and traffic, according to The Press Democrat.
Despite those concerns, commissioners backed the revamped proposal unanimously. Commissioner Alex Myers called the plan a remarkable preservation effort, the outlet reported, signaling that at least for the planning body, the promise of a revived historic building outweighed the sticking points…