A Manhattan Co-op Owner Faces a Six-Figure Legal Bill in a 3-Year Fight Over a Shower Leak That 10 City Inspectors Say Does Not Exist

Two numbers sit at the center of a fight inside a Manhattan co-op: roughly $170,000 to $200,000 in legal fees that the building wants from one shareholder, and 10 city inspections that, by her account, found no leak. The New York Post laid out the dispute on Nov. 11 from court papers and interviews.

Guillermina Girardi lives in Castle Village, a hillside complex in Hudson Heights. Her co-op says her shower is leaking into the bathroom below and wants it redone at her expense. She says nothing is leaking, and the case is now in its third year.

A Small Leak in Spring 2023 That Never Went Away

According to the Post’s account, Girardi bought her one-bedroom in January 2023 for $660,000. About six weeks after she moved in, the downstairs neighbors reported “a small leak. It does not seem serious,” in an email from the managing agent quoted in court papers. Disputes over who pays when water moves between apartments are not unusual, as a Texas woman found in a six-year fight with her HOA, and anyone facing a drip of their own may like a guide to fixing a leaky bathtub faucet.

Months later, management described the problem as “an uninhabitable situation,” the Post reported. The co-op has been in court with Girardi ever since, a long way from the friendlier picture in a list of habits of neighbors people are lucky to have. The Post said the building’s lawyer, Ingrid Manevitz of Seyfarth Shaw, declined to comment, as did the co-op’s management…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS