A coffin over dinner should feel like a warning. At The Old Canal Inn in Nutley, it somehow feels like part of the charm.
One minute you’re walking into what looks like a no-nonsense North Jersey neighborhood bar, and the next you’re looking around at skeletons, old photos, dark wood, ceiling oddities, and a roped-off bar seat with a reputation bad enough to earn its own burger.
This is not a sleek cocktail lounge trying to look haunted for social media…