If you have ever debated driving across Ohio for dessert, Der Dutchman in Plain City makes a very convincing argument. This beloved family restaurant pairs hearty Amish cooking with a bakery case full of pies that look like they came straight from a church supper table.
With a huge dining room, a loyal following, and thousands of glowing reviews, it is the kind of place that turns an ordinary meal into a day trip. Come hungry, save room for pie, and do not be surprised if you leave planning your next visit before you hit the parking lot.
1. The pies that steal the whole show
The biggest reason to make the trip to Der Dutchman is simple: the pies. They look old-fashioned in the best possible way, with tall slices, flaky crusts, glossy fruit fillings, and cream tops that practically dare you to skip dessert.
Even after a full meal, you will probably find yourself making room because passing them up feels impossible…